Introduction to Walmart’s Pumpkin Pie
Good old pumpkin pie, the kind Walmart used to make, has been put to the test. To put it bluntly, the megachain that can buy anything still bakes and sells the classic Christmas desserts, but that doesn’t mean everyone thinks they necessarily should.
The Verdict on Walmart’s Pumpkin Pie
Chowhound tasted and rated six store-bought pumpkin pies, and the Walmart bakery’s version came in last place. The taster and author, who went into the tasting with high hopes, described the $5, 8-inch, bland Thanksgiving pastry as having a “weird sour aftertaste.” The tin felt slippery and oily, and the cake itself ended up splitting in the middle, not holding together very well.
A Disappointing Experience
The experience was disappointing, especially considering the author had previously enjoyed Walmart’s inexpensive, hearty beef pot roast soup. The pumpkin pie was described as having a weird sour aftertaste, which is not what one expects from a dessert. This has led to the conclusion that Walmart’s take on this popular cake flavor is pretty crumbly.
Reviews from Other Customers
Reviews from other customers on YouTube and the product page came to similar conclusions. One dissatisfied reviewer wrote, "I’m craving pumpkin pie, but not this pumpkin pie. The texture is unpleasant – soggy and dry, and the pumpkin flavor just tastes bad. There are flavors of spices and sugar, but you can’t taste pumpkin at all. If pumpkin pie tasted like that, it wouldn’t be a seasonal favorite or treat."
Alternative Options
It might be better to stick with other bakery fan favorites, such as Marketside Ice Cream Lemon Loaf Cake, and leave the pumpkin pie to the professionals (or your grandma). This way, you can ensure a delicious and satisfying dessert experience.
