Introduction to the Dispute
The dispute between Europe and Washington over online regulations has escalated. On Christmas Eve, the White House imposed visa bans on five public figures in Europe. This move is a response to what European officials call regulation of online damage, while American officials view it as censorship.
Background of the Dispute
The most prominent figure facing travel restrictions is Thierry Breton, a former EU commissioner responsible for regulating social media and a key architect of the Digital Services Act (DSA). The Trump administration has accused the EU of inappropriately restricting freedom of expression in its efforts to combat hate speech, misinformation, and disinformation. The administration argues that the DSA unfairly targets U.S. companies.
Key Figures Involved
Mr. Breton has had heated arguments with Elon Musk, the owner of X and a former Trump adviser. Earlier this year, Musk called him a "tyrant of Europe," and Mr. Breton accused Musk of "lying like hell" about the online restrictions he faces. The other four people facing visa bans are from Britain and Germany and work in disinformation organizations.
European Online Regulations
Europe and the UK have much tighter controls on what can be done online compared to America. The Digital Services Act regulates online activities in Europe, while the UK has the Online Security Act. These laws govern what can be said online and can result in prison sentences if violated.
Consequences of the Dispute
Just this month, ex-footballer Joey Barton was given a suspended six-month prison sentence for "grossly offensive" posts he sent on X. Under both laws, platforms that host harmful content can face significant fines, even if they are based in the US. Musk’s Platform X was recently fined €120m (£104m) by the EU on questions of transparency.
Reaction to the Visa Bans
The EU Commission strongly condemned the visa bans, and the British government said it "supports the laws and institutions that work to keep the internet free of the most harmful content." The politician who replaced Breton in his role as European Commissioner, said: "No sanction will silence the sovereignty of the European peoples. Total solidarity with him and all the people of Europe affected by it."
