Introduction to the Public Inquiry
An NHS trust that grieving families claim provided "chaotic and appalling" mental health care will be the subject of a public inquiry. The investigation into the Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Trust (TEWV) was announced after years of campaigning by the families of Christie Harnett, Nadia Sharif, and Emily Moore, who all died by suicide after being treated at West Lane Hospital in Middlesbrough.
Background of the Incident
The trust said it would "fully support the process with transparency, openness and humility". Health Minister Wes Streeting stated that he was grateful to all the families who shared their stories and acknowledged that what happened to their loved ones was unacceptable. He praised the families’ courageous and tireless efforts in seeking a public inquiry, not just for their own families but for all those in urgent need of psychological support.
The Public Inquiry
The investigation will focus on "exposing failings in care" at TEWV and will be conducted separately from other ongoing investigations into mental health services. Andy McDonald, who supported the families in their appeals, said the announcement came with a "sense of vindication" and reflected years of tireless efforts. He emphasized that it was vital for all public services to be held to account.
Response from the Trust
Alison Smith, chief executive of TEWV, said she wanted to see trust strengthened further and acknowledged the obligation to listen, reflect, and take meaningful action to ensure continual improvement as an organization. The trust had previously apologized and was ordered to pay £215,000 for safety failings that contributed to the deaths of Miss Harnett and another unnamed patient.
The Families’ Experience
Miss Harnett’s stepfather, Michael Harnett, described the conditions at West Lane Hospital as "horrible", with patients hurting themselves and walking around covered in blood. He questioned why the situation was allowed to get so bad and why it had been allowed to continue. He fears that more people will die without answers.
The Campaign for a Public Inquiry
Emily Moore’s father, David, said the campaign for a public inquiry had kept him going, and he wants to ensure that what happened to his daughter does not happen to other families. The Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys Trust serves a population of around two million people across County Durham, Teesside, and North Yorkshire, making it one of the largest trusts in the country.
Conclusion
The public inquiry into the Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Trust is a significant step towards exposing failings in care and ensuring that those responsible are held to account. The families of Christie Harnett, Nadia Sharif, and Emily Moore have fought tirelessly for justice, and their efforts have finally been recognized. The inquiry will provide a platform for the families to share their stories and seek answers, and it is hoped that it will lead to meaningful changes in the way mental health care is provided.
