Introduction to the Case
Harvey Weinstein’s lawyers initially thought that their client’s health issues would prevent him from making it through his New York rape trial alive. However, they have now decided on a different approach. The producer will not testify in his own defense, a decision that has been described as advisory, much like the approach taken in the movie "Pulp Fiction".
The Decision Not to Testify
Weinstein’s long-time spokesman, Juda Engelmayer, explained that while Weinstein wanted to testify, his team decided against it. "He wanted to testify and we respect this instinct," Engelmayer said. "At this stage, he would submit it far beyond the scope of the current charges in this phase – raise problems that could wrongly damage its credibility. Our position is careful not to avoid." This decision was made after a weekend of deliberation, during which the final decision went back and forth.
Previous Attempts to Testify
This is not the first time Weinstein has wanted to testify in his own defense. In his original NYC trial and in a 2022 case in Los Angeles, he also expressed a desire to take the stand, but ultimately did not.
The Trial Proceedings
With Weinstein not testifying, the jury will likely hear final arguments from the defense and the Manhattan office on Tuesday afternoon, with the defense resting its case by Wednesday morning. The jury of seven women and five men will then begin deliberating on Weinstein’s fate.
Public Statements
Despite not testifying in court, Weinstein has been conducting a kind of guerrilla-PR campaign during the trial. In a jailhouse interview with Candace Owens, he claimed that he had not committed the crimes he is accused of. He also told Owens that he had been wrongly accused, saying "I swear that God and the people who are now and to my family are wrongly accused."
The Defense Strategy
Weinstein’s defender, Arthur Aidala, has argued that the relationships between Weinstein and his accusers, Jessica Mann, Miriam Haley, and Kaja Sokola, were consensual and involved "arrangements". Aidala has also highlighted the changes in society and the #metoo movement since 2017, which he believes have impacted the case.
Current Status
Weinstein is currently imprisoned for sex crimes, serving a 23-year sentence from a 2020 conviction. He is also facing an additional count of criminal sexual act in the first degree, which was added to the indictment in September. A new judge has been assigned to the case, and Weinstein’s team is hoping for a more favorable outcome.
